One Mystery Toastie
One little surprise just for you.
$14.99
1
- Ships in 1–3 days · free over $35
- 1 random Toastie · rare chance in every bag
Series 1 · 8 Toasties to collect
Meet the Toasties
Soft, slow-rising mystery squishies with a surprise in every bag. Unwrap yours, collect them all, and see if you're lucky enough to find a rare Toastie!
Three Mystery Toasties
Triple the squish, triple the fun.
$39.99$13.33 per Toastie
1
- Free shipping · ships in 1–3 days
- 3 random Toasties · rare chance in every bag
Six Mystery Toasties
For the ultimate Toasties obsession.
$74.99$12.50 per Toastie
1
- Free shipping · ships in 1–3 days
- 6 random Toasties · rare chance in every bag
- Slow-rising foam
- Mystery surprise
- 2 rare finds
Squish Zone
GO AHEAD… GIVE ME A SQUISH!
Warning: Extremely Addicting ♡
Butter Toastie
Tip: press & hold for a deep squish
You've squished me 0 times!
The collection
MEET THE TOASTIES ♡
Every slice has a little personality.
Wanted ✦ Rare
Wanted ✦ Rare
Just for fun
WHAT'S INSIDE YOUR TOASTIE BAG?
Tap the bag to give it a shake…
Just for fun! Your actual mystery Toastie is revealed when your order arrives.
So much love
WHY EVERYONE LOVES TOASTIES
Super soft & satisfying
Squeeze it flat and watch it slooowly rise back. Pure stress-melting foam therapy.
Adorable collectible characters
Eight little slices, eight big personalities. Which one is your toast twin?
Mystery surprises
Every bag is sealed, so the unwrap moment is always a sweet little surprise.
Rare Toasties to discover
Burnt and Moldy are hiding out there. Will you be the lucky one to find them?
Join the Toasties Club ♡
Be the first to hear about new drops, secret characters, and cute surprises!
FAQ
Questions? We've got answers ♡
Still curious? Say hi to our support team